Unpatched Apache reverse proxy flaw puts networks at risk
Security researcher reveals how to bypass older patch for an Apache reverse proxy vulnerability
By Lucian Constantin | Published: 12:00, 28 November 2011
A yet-to-be-patched flaw discovered in the Apache HTTP server allows attackers to access protected resources on the internal network if some rewrite rules are not defined properly.
The vulnerability affects Apache installations that operate in reverse proxy mode, a type of configuration used for load balancing, caching and other operations that involve the distribution of resources over multiple servers.
In order to set up Apache HTTPD to run as a reverse proxy, server administrators use specialised modules like mod_proxy and mod_rewrite.
Related Articles on Techworld
Configuring rules properly
Security researchers from Qualys warn that if certain rules are not configured correctly, attackers can trick servers into performing unauthorised requests to access internal resources.
The problem isn't new and a vulnerability that allowed similar attacks was addressed back in October. However, while reviewing the patch for it, Qualys researcher Prutha Parikh realised that it can be bypassed due to a bug in the procedure for URI (Uniform Resource Identifier) scheme stripping. The scheme is the URI part that comes before the colon ":" character, such as http, ftp or file.
One relatively common rewrite and proxying rule is "^(.*) http://internal_host$1", which redirects the request to the machine internal_host. However, if this is used and the server receives, for example, a request for "host::port" (with two colons), the "host:" part is stripped and the rest is appended to http://internal_host in order to forward it internally.
The problem is that in this case, the remaining part is ":port", therefore transforming the forwarded request into http://internal_host:port, an unintended behavior that can result in the exposure of a protected resource.
Still deciding on a fix
In order to mitigate the problem server administrators should add a forward slash before $1 in the rewrite rule, the correct form being "^(.*) http://internal_host/$1", Parikh said.
The Apache developers are aware of the problem and are currently discussing the best method of fixing it. One possibility would be to strengthen the previous patch in the server code in order to reject such requests, however, there's no certainty that other bypass methods won't be discovered.
"We could try improve that fix, but I think it would be simpler to change the translate_name hooks in mod_proxy and mod_rewrite to enforce the requirement in the 'right' place," said Red Hat senior software engineer Joe Orton on the Apache dev mailing list. Orton proposed a patch that is currently being reviewed by the other developers.