Engineers demand price drop for 100G ethernet
Mainstream adoption held up by astronomical pricing
By Jim Duffy | Network World US | Published: 10:03, 26 February 2010
Though demand for 40G and 100G Ethernet is on the rise, prices need to come down to earth before mainstream adoption can occur, experts at an Ethernet conference said here this week.
Currently, the cost of a 40G Ethernet link on single mode or multimode fibre is about $8,000, or six or seven times that of a 10G link, participants at the Ethernet Technology Summit said. A 100G Ethernet link on single mode or multimode fiber can cost $25,000, up to 20 times that of a 10G Ethernet interface, they say. Such economics, coupled with the fact that the IEEE 802.3ba standard for 40/100G Ethernet is still three to four months from ratification, is keeping demand muted even though interest is high.
"We want the race car without paying race car prices," Brad Booth, founder and board chair of the Ethernet Alliance, said during his keynote address. "The cost of the optics is still not competitive. That's where this industry needs to focus."
Related Articles on Techworld
Analyst Michael Howard of Infonetics Research says it will be 2015 before 100G Ethernet is priced for the market. The price differentials are similar to those of 1G to 10G Ethernet when 10G emerged. At that time, 10G cost $39,000 per port. Participants at the Ethernet Technology Summit say 40G Ethernet will eventually follow a similar price decline curve as 10G when it ships in increasing volumes. And 100G is expected to follow 40G's declines.
Paul Hooper, chief marketing officer at Extreme Networks, says his company is working on 40G and 100G Ethernet interface modules. There is pent-up demand for 40G Ethernet switching in the banking, healthcare and media markets – the same customers that buy Extreme's "40/100G ready" Summit X650 and BlackDiamond 8900 switches, he says. As for 100G Ethernet, there is interest among Extreme customers but not real demand, Hooper says.
Activity in 40G may start to ramp fairly soon. In addition to the standard being ratified in June, Summit participants say they expect 40G Ethernet products to be introduced and on demonstration at the Interop trade show and conference in April.
"We think that 40G is due even though we're just ramping up 10G Ethernet," says Bill Lee, senior product marketing manager at Mellanox, a maker of Infiniband and Ethernet data centre switches.
Mellanox introduced a 40G Ethernet adapter last September that it sells to OEMs for $5,000. Mellanox expects to sell more of the adapters once switches equipped with 40G Ethernet ports emerge later this year. Nonetheless, the company received two inquiries in the past week for the 40G Ethernet card, Lee says. As for 100G, Mellanox expects to introduce a 100Gbps Infiniband adapter in early 2011. A 100G Ethernet module will follow shortly thereafter, Lee says.
Another data center switch maker, BLADE Network Technologies, expects to trial switches with 40G Ethernet ports in the second half of 2010, says Dan Tuchler, BLADE vice president of strategy and product management.
He sees 40G Ethernet as a practical solution for the next three or four years. A single 40G Ethernet interface will reduce a lot of the cable spaghetti cooked up by users aggregating four 10G links into a logical 40G pipe. BLADE switches with 100G Ethernet interfaces are still at least a year away, Tuchler says. Even then, he doesn't see 100G Ethernet in data centres until 2013 or 2014. "There's demand for it," Tuchler says. "But when do you make it cost effective?"