Bluetooth vendors blocked by patent suit
Another weak signal.
By Nancy Gohring, IDG News Service | Published: 13:59, 03 January 2007
Just as the number of Bluetooth device users passed the billion mark, a lawsuit threatens the momentum of the short range wireless technology.
A Washington state organisation sued Nokia, Samsung, Panasonic of North America and Matsushita for making and selling Bluetooth products that infringe on at least one patent.
The Washington Research Foundation (WRF), a non-profit organisation that helps Washington state universities and research institutes commercialise technologies and also helps fund research at such organisations, filed the suit on Dec 21 in the U.S. District Court for the Western district of Washington.
The legal action comes as a surprise to some members of the Bluetooth Special Interest Group (SIG), which was created to control and protect the technology behind the standard.
The more than 6,000 companies that belong to the Bluetooth SIG agree to license their relevant patents to other members without cost, said Anders Edlund, marketing director for the Bluetooth SIG. The group also has done legal investigations to ensure that companies can build Bluetooth products without infringing on patents. "It seems to have worked so far so this [lawsuit] was kind of a surprise," he said.
The WRF claims that at least one of its patents related to radio frequency receivers is used in the Bluetooth standard.
That patent was filed in August 2003 and granted Oct 3, 2006. The first version of the Bluetooth specification was approved in 1998 and several updates have passed since.
While Broadcom, a mobile phone chip maker, licenses patents from WRF, CSR PLC, a U.K. chip maker that supplies Nokia and the other defendants, doesn't, the WRF said.
The WRF asks the court to forbid the companies from importing or selling the relevant Bluetooth products in the U.S. and also asks for damages for historical infringement.
The Bluetooth SIG hasn't had the chance to take a close look at the suit yet to determine if it thinks the claims are valid, according to Edlund. "Obviously any legal issue with the technology is a concern to us," he said.
These types of lawsuits, launched by companies that claim they have technology essential to existing standards, aren't completely uncommon, according to Stefan Svedberg, a Bluetooth SIG board member and an executive with Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson. "The set up of the SIG is something that would minimise this risk but it's not a surprise that there might be some parties like this out there," he said.