Austrian court rejects Facebook 'class action' privacy suit, refers it to another court
The commercial court referred referred the case to the regional court
By Loek Essers | Published: 12:08, 08 August 2014
A 'class action' suit against Facebook over its privacy policies was rejected by the commercial court of Vienna, and referred to the regional court in the same city, a commercial court spokesman said Friday.
"It is a claim that doesn't belong at the commercial court but belongs at the regional court for civil cases," the commercial court's spokesman said, calling it a procedural decision.
The judge responsible for the case will now assess the merits of the case and determine if the regional court has the right jurisdiction, a spokeswoman for the regional court said. A decision to accept or reject the case will be made "as quickly as possible", she said.
How long this will take is difficult to say at the moment because it is the middle of the summer holiday period, she said, adding that it should be a matter of days rather than weeks. If the court accepts the case, it has to serve notice on Facebook Ireland, which is the defendant in the case. This could take some time too, as the notice might have to be translated first, she added.
Max Schrems, a privacy campaigner and the front man of the Austrian group Europe-v-Facebook, announced last Friday that he sued Facebook Ireland, which is responsible for processing the data of users outside the U.S. and Canada, at the commercial court in Vienna for violating EU privacy laws.
Being referred to another court "is not a big deal," Schrems said. "To us it doesn't really matter what court we end up in," he said.
Facebook users outside of the U.S. and Canada were invited to join his claim, which they did in large numbers. On Wednesday the number of participants reached a self-set limit 25,000 Facebook users, each claiming €500 (US$670) in damages, amounting to a total claim of €12.5 million. Users can still register on fbclaim.com and may be added to the case later. Over 20,000 additional Facebook users registered after the limit was reached, Europe-v-Facebook said Friday.
Under Austrian law, a U.S.-style class action suit in which people can collectively sue a company isn't possible. However, interested parties are allowed to assign their claims to a single person who can then sue on behalf of the third parties and redistribute any damages awarded.
The case was referred on Tuesday because the lawsuit mainly covers privacy law matters which should be dealt with by the regional civil court, Schrems said. Schrems and his team had decided to file the suit first with the commercial court because there were other matters in the suit that should be dealt with by the commercial court under Austrian law, he said.
Schrems is still confident that the court will accept the case, because the commercial court also could have rejected the case without referring it, he said.
In Germany for example severallawsuits against Facebook Ireland over privacy matters were rejected by courts that argued that because Facebook's European headquarters is located in Ireland, Irish law applies. However, another German court ruled last year that German data protection law does apply to Facebook, contradicting the other decisions.
The issue of jurisdiction will probably be a big part of Facebook's defence, said Schrems, adding that they will probably argue that they should be sued in California, where Facebook is based.
However, because Schrems is Austrian, he should be able to sue Facebook Ireland in his home court, he said.
Loek is Amsterdam Correspondent and covers online privacy, intellectual property, open-source and online payment issues for the IDG News Service. Follow him on Twitter at @loekessers or email tips and comments to firstname.lastname@example.org