Follow Us

We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message

Apple, Samsung bicker over jury verdict form

As the case approaches its end, the attention of lawyers turns to the questions asked of the jury

Article comments

As the second jury trial between Apple and Samsung approaches its conclusion, the companies are sparring over the precise questions the jury will be asked to consider.

On Thursday morning, Judge Lucy Koh published a tentative verdict form with 15 questions, each broken into multiple parts. A count through the document reveals 245 decisions and calculations the jury will be asked to make.

For example, a question about whether Samsung infringed Apple's slide-to-unlock patent must be considered for six accused phones and two accused companies -- Samsung Electronics and Samsung Telecommunications America. That's 12 separate decisions for the jury to make.

Each side submitted their own proposed verdict form about three weeks ago, and the judge's tentative form is based on those. It's a lot closer to Apple's proposal than Samsung's, which ran almost double the length of what the judge proposed.

Judge Koh asked for feedback Thursday and it came back fast, with Apple saying the form was too complex and Samsung calling it too simple.

The number of questions the jury has to consider is significant, because as more questions are asked, the more potential there is for problems and objections that could lead to a mistrial.

Apple's objection to the judge's verdict form focused on a question originally proposed by Samsung that asks the jury to break down any damages Samsung should pay not just by product but also by patent.

Apple said the question "substantially increases the risk of a mistrial based on future claims by Samsung that the jury's calculations are inconsistent."

"The jury would need to do additional math to incorporate the per-patent and per-product breakdowns," Apple said, noting neither side provided such a breakdown during the trial.

Apple has good reason to worry about the jury's math: A previous lawsuit between the companies had to be partly retried because the jurors had miscalculated the damages.

Samsung said it wants a more detailed verdict form so it can see how the jury arrives at any damages. Its own proposal would allow for "a more transparent understanding of the jury's damages award, if any," it said.

Judge Koh doesn't have long to rule. The two sides are due back in court Friday, when they will rest their respective cases. Closing statements are set for Monday and the jury will begin its deliberations the same day.

Martyn Williams covers mobile telecoms, Silicon Valley and general technology breaking news for The IDG News Service. Follow Martyn on Twitter at @martyn_williams. Martyn's e-mail address is martyn_williams@idg.com



Share:

More from Techworld

More relevant IT news

Comments



Send to a friend

Email this article to a friend or colleague:

PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story, and in case of transmission error. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.

Techworld White Papers

Choose – and Choose Wisely – the Right MSP for Your SMB

End users need a technology partner that provides transparency, enables productivity, delivers...

Download Whitepaper

10 Effective Habits of Indispensable IT Departments

It’s no secret that responsibilities are growing while budgets continue to shrink. Download this...

Download Whitepaper

Gartner Magic Quadrant for Enterprise Information Archiving

Enterprise information archiving is contributing to organisational needs for e-discovery and...

Download Whitepaper

Advancing the state of virtualised backups

Dell Software’s vRanger is a veteran of the virtualisation specific backup market. It was the...

Download Whitepaper

Techworld UK - Technology - Business

Innovation, productivity, agility and profit

Watch this on demand webinar which explores IT innovation, managed print services and business agility.

Techworld Mobile Site

Access Techworld's content on the move

Get the latest news, product reviews and downloads on your mobile device with Techworld's mobile site.

Find out more...

From Wow to How : Making mobile and cloud work for you

On demand Biztech Briefing - Learn how to effectively deliver mobile work styles and cloud services together.

Watch now...

Site Map

* *